Schematic Design in Construction: Establishing the Vision with SD Drawings

Every construction project begins with a vision, but turning that vision into reality involves numerous steps and considerations. How will the spaces flow and interact? What design elements will best meet the project's goals? How can stakeholders ensure the project's feasibility and alignment with client expectations? These foundational questions are addressed during the early stages of project planning.

The approach to this schematic design phase can vary greatly, depending on the project's scope, the design team's methodology, and the client's requirements. In Canada, this phase must comply with standards set by the National Building Code of Canada and local and provincial regulations. Understanding the nuances of this stage is important for avoiding design pitfalls and ensuring a smooth progression through the subsequent stages of design and construction.

In this article, we look into the intricacies of schematic design in construction, highlighting its importance and exploring the process.

What is schematic design?

Schematic design, or SD for short, is one of the earliest phases of the architectural design process. This phase involves creating early construction documents and moving beyond preliminary sketches to offer a structured representation of the project. These documents incorporate inputs from the entire architectural team, including key engineering consultants. 

The primary purpose of schematic design is to document the key architectural and engineering elements that capture the project's vision and requirements. From the architect's perspective, they are flushing out the central idea or concept, or parti, of the building. 

For instance, while detailed structural elements are not fully fleshed out, the schematic design ensures that the building has walls in the right place, circulation paths roughly worked out, and a basic structure and systems in place, avoiding the impracticality of a "floating building" and any skyhook jokes that the structural engineering team will make. 

Schematic design is also the phase where the design team begins to integrate the client's input, often using information from feasibility studies or master plans. These plans and studies often impact the building footprint, volume, and other site considerations like overall building orientation and entrance location.  

Schematic Design vs. Other Design Phases

Schematic design stands apart from other phases of the design process, design development, and construction documents by its distinct focus on conceptualization and early-stage planning. Unlike the later phases, which delve into details and precise specs, schematic design drawings provide a broad, less detailed overview that sets the initial direction for the project. 

In the schematic design phase, the emphasis is on defining the project's basic layout and overall concept. This involves creating preliminary construction drawings that capture the essential elements and spatial relationships without going into the minutiae of minor material selection, choosing each type of finish and detailing each intersection. 

For example, while later phases will specify the types and locations of mechanical systems and structural components in great detail, the schematic design will only broadly outline these elements, ensuring that the basic framework is understood and agreed upon.

Transitioning to Design Development and Construction Documents

The design development phase builds upon the foundations laid during schematic design. It involves refining the project's details, such as selecting materials, defining structural components and integrating systems like HVAC (heating, ventilation, and air conditioning), plumbing, and electrical. The documents produced in this phase are more detailed and precise, bridging the gap between the broad concepts of schematic design and the comprehensive specificity of construction documents.

Construction documents represent the final phase before tendering starts on a project. This phase produces highly detailed drawings and specs that contractors use to build the project. Every aspect of the design is fully fleshed out, from the exact placement of every wall and window to the specific materials. These documents help make sure the project is built according to the design intent and meets all regulatory and safety standards, like the Canada Occupational Health and Safety Regulations and Workplace Hazardous Materials Information System (WHMIS). 

Initiating the Schematic Design Phase

The schematic design phase is typically the first formal step in transforming a project's vision into a concrete plan. This is normally the moment when an architectural firm is contracted to bring the building from concept through the drawings and design phases to 100% construction documents for tendering to contractors.

Owner Project Approval and Funding

The schematic design phase typically begins once the owner has received initial approval and funding for the project. This approval marks the transition from conceptual discussions to formal planning, where the design team can start to develop a tangible representation of the project. This phase is crucial for setting the project on a solid foundation, ensuring that all stakeholders are aligned with the project's vision and goals.

Gathering Information

The process often starts with the architect and design team gathering information from various sources such as feasibility studies, master plans, or client directives. Larger clients, such as universities or municipalities, often have master plans that provide a comprehensive roadmap for future developments. These master plans are invaluable as they outline the broader context within which the new project will be developed, including zoning, site conditions, and long-term strategic goals. It is essential to understand the client's existing plans, their requirements, and how this project fits in.

Role of the Architectural Team

The architect, their partner engineering firms, and other key consultants typically submit a joint proposal to the client. However, the architect is generally one of the main contract holders. This setup is common for building design projects, though large civil or landscape projects might have a different arrangement. 

Early collaboration with engineering consultants is key to ensuring the feasibility of the proposed design. Engineers provide critical input on structural integrity, mechanical systems, and compliance with zoning regulations. This collaborative approach helps identify potential challenges early on and allows for adjustments before moving into more detailed phases of design, which can prevent costly revisions, resulting in a smoother project delivery.

Key Components of Schematic Design

During the schematic design phase, several key elements guide the project's development. 

Basic Layout and Structure

The schematic design phase is a key step in establishing the basic layout and structural elements of a project. During this phase, the design team begins to document the fundamental components that will define the building, including the placement of walls and the organization of primary systems such as HVAC.

By documenting and establishing these key elements early on, the design team ensures that the project remains cohesive and that all required systems and spaces are effectively integrated.

Program Requirements

Programming is a process within a schematic design that determines the spatial needs and functional requirements of the building. This involves a detailed analysis of what the building must accommodate, from the number of bathrooms to the specific requirements of specialized rooms.

Zoning and Site Analysis

Zoning analysis and understanding site constraints are vital components of the schematic design phase. Zoning laws, varying as per the provinces, dictate how a piece of land can be used and what can be built on it, impacting the building's footprint and overall layout. The design team must thoroughly review these regulations to ensure compliance and identify potential challenges early in the process. 

Understanding the site itself is equally important. The design team must assess site conditions such as topography, soil quality, existing infrastructure, and compliance with environmental regulations set by associations like the Canadian Environmental Assessment Agency (CEAA). These factors can affect everything from the building's foundation to its access points and utility connections.

Collaborative Nature of Schematic Design

Schematic design thrives on collaboration, bringing together architects, engineers, consultants, and clients to shape the project's foundational concepts. This phase is not just about the design team working in isolation; it is a collective effort where input from various stakeholders is key. Each brings a unique perspective and expertise, ensuring that all aspects of the project are considered and addressed.

Role of Client Feedback

Client feedback is integral to the schematic design phase. Regular and structured meetings with the client allow the design team to present their progress, gather valuable input, and make necessary adjustments. This feedback loop helps the evolving design align with the client's vision and expectations.

Iterative Process

The schematic design phase is inherently iterative. Initial designs are continually refined and developed through multiple rounds of feedback and revisions. This iterative process is essential for aligning the design with the client's goals and addressing emerging issues or preferences.

Tapping into the Expertise of Engineers and Specialized Consultants

Involving engineers and specialized consultants early in the design process ensures that proposed designs are feasible and compliant with all relevant regulations.

Engineers play a pivotal role in the schematic design phase by providing input on structural feasibility and systems integration. Their expertise helps guarantee the conceptual designs proposed by architects are practical and buildable. 

Engineers assess whether all structural and mechanical components, such as HVAC systems, can be effectively integrated into the design without compromising space or functionality. They evaluate the load-bearing capacity, spatial requirements for mechanical systems, and overall feasibility to ensure that the final design will accommodate all necessary systems while maintaining the desired layout and structural integrity.

In addition to general engineering input, specialized consultants are often brought in for projects with unique requirements. These experts provide targeted advice and solutions for specific aspects of the design that require specialized knowledge. 

Importance of Early Collaboration

Early collaboration with engineers and consultants confirms that the design is both practical and compliant with all relevant codes and regulations. This early involvement helps to identify potential challenges and constraints that might not be apparent in the initial conceptual designs. By addressing these issues early, the design team can make necessary adjustments before moving into more detailed phases, saving time and resources in the long run. 

Documents Produced During Schematic Design

During the schematic design phase, the architectural team produces various essential documents that serve as the foundation for further development.

• Site Plans

  These are comprehensive maps detailing the project's location, including surrounding infrastructure and key geographical features. Site plans are key for understanding how the building interacts with the surrounding environment and for compliance with zoning and site constraints.

• Floor Plans
  

  Floor plans provide a bird's-eye view of each floor of the building, showing the layout of rooms, walls, and other structural elements. These plans help with visualizing the flow of spaces within the building and determining the placement of key elements such as doors and windows.

• Elevations

  Elevations depict the exterior view of the building from various angles, showcasing the design's aesthetic and structural components. These drawings help in understanding the building's appearance and its relationship with the surrounding areas.

• Sections

  Sections are cutaway views that reveal the building's interior structure, illustrating the relationship between different floors and spaces. These documents are important for understanding the vertical dimensions of the project and for planning mechanical and structural systems.

• Parti Diagram

  A parti diagram is a preliminary sketch that outlines the general shape and layout of the building. It serves as a conceptual representation of the project's main ideas and organizational principles. This diagram is used to convey the fundamental design concepts and spatial relationships in a simplified form, making it easier to communicate the project's vision to clients and stakeholders.

Digital Tools and Schematic Design

Digital tools play a crucial role in the schematic design phase, aiding in the creation and management of the various documents produced. One of the primary tools used is Building Information Modelling (BIM) software, which allows the design team (including subconsultants) to create detailed 3D models of the project to be used to generate accurate site plans, floor plans, elevations, and sections.

The use of BIM and other digital tools offers several advantages:

• Accuracy and Precision

  Digital tools enable precise measurements and detailed representations, reducing the likelihood of errors in the design documents.

• Collaboration

  BIM facilitates collaboration among team members by allowing multiple users to work on the same model simultaneously.

• Visualization

  3D models created in BIM provide a realistic representation of the building, making it easier to visualize the final outcome and to identify potential issues early in the design process.

• Flexibility

  Digital tools allow for easy modifications and iterations, enabling the design team to quickly incorporate client feedback and make necessary adjustments.

Strategies for Success in Schematic Design

To streamline the schematic design process and mitigate the challenges of client indecisiveness and evolving requirements, it's important to establish clear guidelines and constraints from the outset. Here are some key considerations.

• Comprehensive Initial Brief

  A detailed initial brief from the client can provide a solid foundation for the design team. This brief should outline the project's goals, requirements, and constraints, helping the design team to align their efforts with the client's vision.

• Regular Check-ins with the Client

  Frequent and structured meetings with the client can help maintain alignment and promptly address concerns. These meetings should be used to review progress, discuss any emerging issues, and confirm decisions so the project stays on track.

• Flexible Yet Structured Approach

  While it is important to have a structured approach to schematic design, incorporating flexibility can help in adapting to any necessary changes without derailing the project. This balance allows the design team to accommodate client feedback while maintaining a clear direction.

• Documenting Changes

  Keeping a detailed record of all changes and their implications can help in managing client expectations and providing transparency regarding the impact on cost and timeline. This documentation is particularly useful in ensuring that all stakeholders are aware of the project's evolution.

Moving Beyond Schematic Design

Transitioning from the schematic design phase to subsequent phases is a key juncture in any project. This phase marks the shift from broad conceptualization to detailed and precise planning, so a project’s foundational ideas are meticulously developed into actionable plans. As the project moves into design development and construction document phases, the level of detail and specificity increases significantly, refining every element from structural components to material selections and system integrations.

The decisions made during the schematic design phase have a profound impact on the entire project lifecycle. Clear, thorough, and well-considered schematic designs streamline subsequent phases, reducing the likelihood of costly changes and delays. Establishing clear guidelines and constraints from the outset, maintaining regular communication with clients, and adopting a flexible yet structured approach are essential strategies for ensuring a successful transition and a coherent design process.

Written by

Reviewed by