Understanding Conceptual Estimating in Construction: From Idea to Reality

At the outset of any construction project, a primary concern for owners is establishing a clear and accurate estimate of project costs. This foundational step influences project funding, budget planning, and design development, setting the stage for the project's success.

Conceptual estimating provides early cost projections based on preliminary project data prior to creating detailed designs. These early estimates are essential for setting initial construction budgets, assessing project feasibility, guiding the design process and supporting strategic decision-making. 

This article explores the art and science of conceptual estimating as well as best practices for pulling together a conceptual estimate.

What is conceptual estimating?

Conceptual estimating, sometimes referred to as cost modeling, is a preconstruction exercise, focused on forecasting project costs before detailed project design and engineering is completed. This process often begins during the predevelopment phase of a project — or as part of a pro forma — to ensure financial viability. 

This practice is deeply intertwined with the project's design status, evolving through various design stages: schematic design, design development, and finally, construction documents. As details are refined through each stage of design, new iterations of the conceptual estimate approach final expected costs. Similarly, at each conceptual estimating milestone, iterations to the scope can be expected, keeping the project’s design intent and budget constraints aligned. 

The goal of conceptual estimating is to steer project decisions to balance design intent, budgetary goals and constructability. Initially, during the schematic stage, designs are often more visionary than practical — usually just sketches or renderings that stimulate discussion rather than serve as buildable drawings. 

As the project progresses into the design development phase, the designs are refined into more detailed and realistic plans, incorporating structural elements, mechanical, electrical and plumbing system components, finishes, etc. However the design may not be “permit ready” just yet.  

Conceptual estimates may include — beyond construction costs — design services and other soft costs, depending on the owner's requirements. Including these elements provides a more holistic view of how much the entire project actually costs. It’s crucial to have thorough preliminary discussions with the owner to confirm and clearly define and document the scope that should be reflected in the estimate, ensuring that all aspects of the project are accurately accounted for from the beginning.

Conceptual estimating is a balance between experience and foresight. Estimators use a variety of data to guide informed predictions, often drawing on historical costs, early design inputs and conversations with the design team, and consultations with specialty contractors to gauge material and labor costs accurately as well as gather feedback on design direction. 

The Role of Conceptual Estimating in Construction

The conceptual estimating process serves a dual role: It acts as both a design guide and a budgetary tool. 

Conceptual estimators collaborate closely with architects and project owners to ensure each design iteration remains aligned with the project's architectural intentions and budgetary goals. This collaboration facilitates cooperative design adjustments and helps project teams ensure that both design and budget goals are feasible or flags when more in-depth design alternatives must be considered to reach said goals. 

Conceptual estimating often involves evaluating and pricing different design scenarios, providing owners with various options to consider. A key practice within this process is the detailed breakdown that separates major cost components, such as structural elements, finishes, site work, etc., allowing stakeholders to pinpoint where costs can be adjusted without compromising design intent. 

 Identifying and evaluating these different scenarios ensures that final decisions regarding project scope are well-informed, viable and align with the overall goals of the project.

Through effective conceptual estimating, owners are equipped to make balanced decisions that optimize aesthetics, functionality and cost.

Challenges of Creating Conceptual Estimates

While conceptual estimating is an essential part of project planning, it presents several challenges. 

Balancing Accuracy and Assumptions

One of the primary challenges in conceptual estimating is maintaining accuracy, which relies heavily on the proper management of assumptions. In the early stages of project planning, details are often not yet concrete, necessitating the use of assumptions to fill in the gaps. 

However, if these assumptions are not clearly documented and communicated, they can lead to significant misunderstandings about the scope and content of the estimate. This lack of clarity can result in discrepancies between the owner’s expectations and the actual project outcomes, potentially leading to conflicts and costly adjustments.

Providing Detailed Documentation

Ensuring thorough documentation is essential to explicitly detail all inclusions, exclusions and assumptions within the estimate. This level of detail is crucial for ensuring that all stakeholders, from project owners to design teams to contractors, fully understand the parameters and limitations of the conceptual budget.

Without comprehensive documentation, the conceptual estimate may not be taken seriously, or worse, could be misinterpreted, leading to misunderstandings between stakeholders that could jeopardize the project’s success. 

Communicating Initial Estimates

The initial estimate establishes a baseline expectation among stakeholders, so accuracy is important even in the early stages. Any subsequent adjustments may be met with resistance or skepticism if it deviates significantly from the initial figure. 

Deviations from the conceptual estimate can create challenges in managing owner expectations and may require additional efforts to realign perceptions with the updated estimates. Providing detailed documentation of the parameters considered in the development of the conceptual estimate can help stakeholders understand the drivers of a significant cost difference. 

Effective communication and transparent discussions are crucial for ensuring that stakeholders understand the evolving nature of estimates and the rationale behind any changes, fostering trust and collaboration throughout the project lifecycle.

Handling Changes in Scope

Changes in project scope during the design development phases can drastically affect the accuracy of conceptual estimates. Adjusting estimates to accommodate these changes without compromising the project's financial feasibility is complex and requires careful management to ensure that all implications are considered, documented and addressed.

Market Fluctuations

Estimators must also contend with the challenge of changing market conditions impacting material prices and labor costs. Accurately forecasting and communicating these anticipated fluctuations and escalations can help to mitigate budget overruns. Additionally, clear communication regarding stakeholder responsibility for cost escalations is essential. Failure to anticipate market trends can lead to significant discrepancies between the estimated and actual costs.

Explore data and trends for building materials prices.

Get the latest U.S. retail prices and view historical trends for common building materials.

Material Price Tracker

8 Best Practices for Conceptual Estimating

Adhering to some best practices in conceptual estimating can enhance the accuracy and effectiveness of project forecasts, aiding financial feasibility and operational efficiency throughout the project lifecycle.

1. Clearly document assumptions and parameters.

One of the fundamental best practices in conceptual estimating involves the meticulous documentation of all assumptions and parameters used in the estimate. This includes detailing what is included and excluded from the scope of an estimate, as well as any assumptions made about project conditions, material costs, labor rates design specifications and price escalation. 

Clear documentation, including careful documentation of differences in iterative estimates or changes between revisions, ensures that all stakeholders — including project owners, architects and contractors— understand the basis of the estimates, reducing the likelihood of miscommunication and scope creep.

2. Establish channels for communication and collaboration.

Effective communication is key throughout the conceptual estimating process. Regular meetings and updates between estimators, project managers, architects and owners help ensure that any changes in project scope or market conditions are promptly addressed. This ongoing dialogue supports the alignment of the project's budgetary and design goals and helps maintain project feasibility.

3. Rely on trusted specialty contractors and engineering partners.

Engaging with subcontractors early in the estimating process is important for obtaining accurate and current data on material costs and labor rates. Subcontractors can provide valuable insights based on their expertise and recent market experiences, which can significantly enhance the accuracy of the estimates. 

Early engagement with subcontractors facilitates a “design-assist” approach where subcontractors across various disciplines collaborate with the design team to identify innovative, cost-effective solutions. This collaboration leads to practical, informed adjustments before finalizing the plans, reducing the need for costly changes during construction.

It also helps in assessing the constructability of the project, providing practical feedback on design issues, value engineering opportunities, and allowing for adjustments in the design before plans are finalized. Incorporating subcontractor insights early not only refines the project's cost but also ensures that the final design is both feasible and economically viable.

4. Approach conceptual estimating as an iterative process.

Conceptual estimating should not be a static activity, but an iterative process, that with each passing iteration, gets more accurate and aligned with project goals. Rather than viewing it as a one-time calculation, conceptual estimating should be seen as a dynamic and evolving endeavor that adapts to changing project requirements and conditions. 

By embracing iteration, estimators can refine their estimates over time, incorporating new information, design revisions and market insights. This approach allows for evolution and continuous improvement, enhancing the reliability and relevance of the estimates as the project progresses through its various stages. 

Moreover, it fosters collaboration and communication among project stakeholders, as feedback and input from architects, engineers, specialty contractors and owners contribute to the refinement of the estimates. Overall, treating conceptual estimating as an evolving process promotes flexibility and responsiveness, ultimately resulting in better project outcomes.

5. Include risk analysis and contingency planning.

In conceptual estimating, risk analysis helps to identify potential cost drivers and uncertainties. By quantifying and prioritizing these risks as well as including contingency budgets, estimators are able to mitigate adverse potential impacts on project budgets. 

A proactive approach to risk management empowers project stakeholders to anticipate and address potential challenges. It’s essential for all project stakeholders to understand that each decision made throughout the project, even during the initial conceptual phase, carries financial implications and requires careful consideration of associated costs. 

Conceptual estimating frames not only the project's budgetary aspects but also significantly influences the schedule, logistics and overall execution strategy. By establishing a clear framework early on in the development process, it ensures better coordination and planning, which are crucial for successful, on-time and cost-conscious project delivery. 

6. Use technology.

Leveraging estimating software can greatly improve the accuracy and efficiency of conceptual estimates. Tools like Microsoft Power BI can manage and streamline massive amounts of data efficiently, transforming raw data into actionable insights. 

Technology can help estimators analyze data more effectively, perform cost comparisons and model different scenarios based on varying design and construction approaches. Using software applications to store and compare historical data can provide reference points that can be adjusted for current market conditions, giving a more realistic basis for new projects. 

Ensuring the integrity and reliability of data is crucial; pulling correct, version-controlled data for accurate cost modeling helps maintain data accuracy throughout the project lifecycle. Estimators often rely on meticulously compiled in-house historical data from similar projects to inform their cost models, ensuring that their estimates reflect real-world outcomes.

7. Incorporate constructability reviews.

Incorporating constructability reviews during the conceptual estimating phase ensures that the project is not only designed to meet aesthetic and functional requirements but is also practical and viable from a construction standpoint. These reviews involve evaluating the project designs from the perspective of those who will build — the general and specialty contractors — identifying potential construction issues early and allowing for design modifications that can prevent costly changes and delays during construction.

8. Consider the latest trends and past lessons.

Lastly, in conceptual estimating, it's essential to maintain a commitment to continual learning and adaptation. The construction industry is dynamic, with evolving techniques, materials and regulations. Estimators must stay informed about these changes and continually adapt their practices and tools to maintain accuracy and relevancy in their estimates. It is also important that conceptual estimators learn from the projects their teams have completed. For example, incorporating lessons learned from recently completed projects can help inform an estimator's approach regarding scope, estimating and/or scheduling. 

By adhering to these best practices, conceptual estimators can provide reliable, accurate forecasts that help ensure projects are completed on time, within budget and align with owner expectations. These practices not only enhance the conceptual estimating process but also contribute to the overall success of construction projects.

Achieving Project Success through Collaboration in Conceptual Estimating

Conceptual estimating blends creativity with pragmatism, but its true strength lies in the collective efforts of those involved. Owners, design teams, and contractors converge, each bringing their expertise to the table and charting a realistic path forward for the project's execution.

This collaborative spirit can help guide every phase of the project, from inception to completion. By engaging in rigorous dialogue, proactive project teams can craft conceptual estimates that enhance the likelihood of hitting the project's goal. It's about fostering an environment where assumptions are laid bare, parameters are defined and communication flows freely.

Conceptual estimating isn't just about crunching numbers: It's about shaping the trajectory of a project, where every decision carries weight. By embracing collaboration, conceptual estimating doesn't just predict costs — it lays the groundwork for success, ensuring projects materialize within defined budgetary parameters and in alignment with the owner’s overarching goals.

Written by