How Performance Bonds Mitigate Risk in Construction Projects

A performance bond provides a guarantee that a contractor will fulfil all of their obligations under a construction agreement. Performance bonds are a subset of contract bonds, in the sense that one party agrees to complete a set amount of work in exchange for a fixed payment, and they guarantee that a contractor will fulfil the terms of the contract. If the contractor fails to do so, then the guarantor – the one providing the performance bond (the money) in the first place – is responsible for completing the contract agreement; they will either hire another contractor or compensate the project financials to the owner-developer. In Australia, performance bonds are a staple in both public and private construction contracts, often aligned with the Australian Standards (AS) forms of contract, which stipulate specific terms and conditions for their use.

There are many types of bonds and insurances used in construction to mitigate risk. The owner-developer (or obligee) may use performance bonds to protect themselves from contractor default, especially for large-scale and public projects. Read on to find out how performance bonds work, why they are important and how to secure a performance bond as a contractor.

How Performance Bonds Work

Performance bonds, which are secured by a contractor before the beginning of a project, provide a guarantee to the owner-developer that the contract agreement will be fulfilled. If the contractor fails to complete the agreed work according to the contract terms, then the owner-developer may receive financial compensation from a guarantor. Alternatively, the guarantor may arrange for another contractor to finish the job, under the same provision of a performance bond agreement, of course.

Under Australian law, the Security of Payment Acts across various states play a crucial role in construction contracts, influencing the use of performance bonds to ensure rapid dispute resolution and risk management.

Different performance bonds guarantee different amounts of financial compensation and security. In most cases, a performance bond is issued for the full amount of the contract, and the premium is calculated at around 1-3% of the total contractor amount. However, there are numerous factors that can affect the price and amount of the performance bond. Different aspects of a company’s history, including their credit status, past financial loss, and organisational structure, may affect the premium on a bond.

There are many steps that contractors can take to reduce their surety bond costs (the premium paid to the guarantor). Some of these actions may help them increase their bond limit, enabling them to accept bigger projects. Consulting a qualified surety broker or agent can help a contractor take the best course of action based on their unique circumstances.

Parties Involved in a Performance Bond Agreement

Owner-developers

The owner-developer, also called the obligee, may require a performance bond for the head contractor on a project. Ultimately, the bond protects the owner-developer from the risk of the job not being finished by the contractor due to default, bankruptcy or other contributing factors.

Head contractors

The head contractor, also called the principal, is the one who secures the performance bond to work on a project. The bond serves as an incentive for the contractor to fulfil the project, for if they fail to do so, then they’ll have to pay back any expenditures (laid out by the guarantor) they owe the owner-developer. Before a performance bond can be secured, the head contractor must indemnify (protect from damage) the guarantor from all losses and/or expenses, which they do by guaranteeing to repay any loss on a bond. Put simply, the indemnity agreement secures the guarantor, giving them access to secure assets for repayment if the situation ever calls for it.

Surety companies

A guarantor is a financial institution that provides the bond to whichever contractor prequalifies for the contract agreement. The guarantor, essentially, evaluates the contractor in question, both in terms of their ability to complete the construction contract (that they have entered into) and that of their financial stability.

Australian surety companies are generally insurance companies regulated by APRA, ensuring they meet the stringent standards required to operate within the nation's construction sector.

If the contractor fails to complete the contract, then the guarantor must provide funds to the owner-developer; at least, until the head contractor repays the guarantor. As a result, the guarantor has a strong financial incentive to provide bonds to only qualified contractors.

Typically, a performance bond is used to lower risk for owner-developers and to give head contractors an incentive to complete the work they agree to do. Ultimately, performance bonds help make sure that the job gets done, whether it be through the original contractor or through the guarantor, who steps in to pick up the pieces and get the project across the finish line.

The Consequences of an Unfulfilled Contract

If a contractor fails to complete a construction contract (under a performance bond arrangement), then the owner-developer can file a claim against the performance bond. If the claim is found to be valid, the guarantor may step in to correct the situation.

In Australia, the Security of Payment legislation allows for rapid adjudication, which is an expedited form of dispute resolution that complements the role of performance bonds.

If a claim is filed by the owner-developer, then the guarantor will investigate the matter; this is to determine if there’s an actual default. The guarantor will assess the work that needs to be done and the cost of any changes. Then, they will complete the project by either: hiring another contractor, or by paying out the owner-developer up to the pre-determined bond limit.

In most cases, a performance bond claim will accompany the termination of the original head contractor, but there are times where an owner-developer will want to avoid termination. Why? Because terminating a contractor can be an expensive and costly process – for all parties involved.

Instead, an owner-developer may explore ways to keep the original head contractor on board, but at a reduced scope; they may reduce the workload, supplement the workforce, or provide advance payment to keep the project moving forward – and the head contractor financially stable. Contractors can then use project management software to adjust the scope, including the allocation of labour and materials to accommodate for these changes. However, failing this, the guarantor will step in.

Every bond has its own approach to determining whether a claim is or is not valid. For example, if the guarantor doesn’t receive a notice of default in a timely manner, then (under the specific terms of their contract) they may have the right to deny the claim.

Additionally, while the performance bond serves to protect the owner-developer from contractor default, the guarantor still has plenty of freedom to remedy a situation. In fact, they may even be able to reinstate the defaulting contractor, whether or not the owner-developer agrees with the decision.

How Surety Companies Respond After a Contractor Defaults

In Australia, the terms of a surety bond must align with the Australian Standard 2124-1992 (General Conditions of Contract). This standard ensures that the wording of a surety bond mimics that of a bank guarantee, meaning that both the guarantor and contractor must follow the same legal obligations as a bank guarantee. Familiarity with this standard is essential to having a legally binding performance bond agreement, as well as collaborating with the Australian Building and Construction Commission (ABCC) in the event of contractor default.

If the contractor is, ultimately, found to be in default, then the guarantor will step in to correct the situation. There are many avenues for the guarantor to explore, but here are some of the most common ways they resolve a claim.

1. Payout. The guarantor will pay either the amount of the bond limit, or the cost of completing the work — whichever is lower.
2. Financing. A guarantor may decide that the contractor was so close to completion, that they will finance the contractor’s completion of the work.
3. Arrangement. Here, the guarantor and the client will work together to finish the contract (under the terms of the performance bond). Typically, the owner-developer will choose a replacement contractor, and the guarantor will absorb any additional costs.
4. Takeover. The guarantor will assume full responsibility for finding and funding a replacement contractor to complete the remaining work.

At the end of the day, the contractor must still compensate the guarantor for any money that is paid out. That’s why communication is so important when dealing with bond claims; contractors should always look for alternative solutions, especially when experiencing problems – and doing so before the issue becomes too serious … and well before a claim is brought to light.

From a contractor’s perspective, avoiding a claim requires not defaulting on a contract – and it’s a situation that, under any circumstances, do they ever want to find themselves in, ever. However, even the most qualified, experienced, and well-prepared contractors can run into unanticipated problems. So, what should a contractor do at the first sign of trouble? Pick up the phone, reach out to their surety broke, and then – in collaboration with the guarantor – form a path to a viable solution. After all, surety brokers are highly skilled in managing these types of scenarios, and they may be able to resolve the matter before the owner-developer has the chance to file a claim.

It's cliché, but it’s true: defense is the best offense, and that applies to bond claims as well. The best way to avoid a claim is to prequalify contractors before hiring them for a contract, and that may involve requiring a performance bond.

The Importance of Performance Bonds

Performance bonds are important because they help mitigate risk for all types of construction projects – and in many public projects, performance bonds are not just a viable option but a legal requirement. There are also performance bonds to help Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander-owned businesses fulfil their contracts.

Performance bonds are integral to ensuring adherence to the Building Code 2016 in Australia, safeguarding the interests of all parties involved in the construction process.

What about private projects? Performance bonds are typically not required for these types of projects, but they are growing in popularity and usage – especially for large, complex commercial projects.

Performance bonds, along with other types of bonds, provide a clear incentive for many parties to work together without worrying about whether the contract will be fulfilled. Also, performance bonds may also be used in conjunction with payment bonds; the performance bond protects the owner-developer from a job not getting completed, while a payment bond protects subcontractors and material suppliers from not getting paid for their work.

Without performance bonds, owner-developers risk an incomplete contract if the contractor they choose does not fulfil their end of the bargain. In short, the system of bonds helps ensure that construction projects get done and everyone involved gets paid.

How to Secure a Performance Bond

The first step to securing a performance bond is to find a reputable surety broker. There are many small and large surety brokers to choose from, with Master Builders Insurance Brokers being one of the most established. Just keep in mind that the size of the broker is not the only deciding factor; also consider their level of experience in your relevant industry (construction), past clients, success stories and technical expertise.

Regardless, it’s important to secure a bond from a guarantor that has experience with the type of construction that you’re undertaking, as they’ll be familiar with the potential risks and challenges involved. This way, in the case of a default, the guarantor will be ready to step in and clean up. You’ll also want them to be intimately familiar with the moving parts of your project, the work required to satisfy the contract, and how to find and assess qualified contractors.

To secure a performance bond in Australia, it's advisable to engage with surety brokers who are not only well-versed in the construction industry but also familiar with the Australian Institute of Building's Code of Professional Conduct.

Performance bonds benefit everyone.

When a head contractor fails to complete a contract under a performance bond, things can spiral out of control quickly. For owner-developers, they receive the assurance that their contract will be completed – no matter what happens. For contractors and suppliers, they can keep the project moving and the cash flow coming in, without having to deal with delays or filing payment bond claims.

Construction intelligence software can help you setup the particulars of a performance bond, ensuring that your project stays on track and within budget as per your unique requirements. It's beneficial to choose construction management software that’s designed for the Australian market, with features that cater to local tax laws, such as GST calculations, and integration with Australian financial and project management practices.

For contractors, you can keep owner-developers and security companies up to date, with real-time data relating to not just the status of your project but also of your financials and compliance requirements. For owner-developers, you get the assurance that your contractors are on the right track to success, and if not, then you can address the situation early to avoid serious default claims.

The use of performance bonds in Australia is part of a broader trend towards enhanced risk mitigation, reflecting the construction industry's commitment to robust project delivery and financial assurance.

Ultimately, everyone benefits from a more streamlined and collaborative construction delivery process – especially when it comes to complex, large-scale projects where the stakes are higher than ever.

Written by